Last reviewed: November 15, 2026
Vicarious liability is a legal rule that makes one person or business responsible for another’s wrongful conduct because of the relationship between them, most often an employer’s responsibility for an employee’s actions on the job. In California, an employer is generally liable for torts an employee commits within the scope of employment, even if the employer did nothing wrong itself. This article explains how courts apply the rule, what the scope of employment test means, how independent contractors and vehicle owners are treated, and what defenses are available.
What Is Vicarious Liability in California?
Vicarious liability is liability imposed on one party for the conduct of another, based on their relationship rather than on the first party’s own fault. The most common form is respondeat superior, a Latin phrase meaning “let the master answer,” under which an employer answers for the negligent or wrongful acts of its employees committed in the course of their work.
California codifies the principle in Civil Code section 2338, which makes a principal responsible to third parties for the negligence and wrongful acts of its agent in the transaction of the principal’s business. The policy behind the rule is that a business that profits from its employees’ work should bear the foreseeable risks of that work, and that it is better positioned to spread those costs through insurance and pricing. For employers, these claims are among the most common issues in business litigation.
How Do Courts Decide Whether Conduct Was Within the Scope of Employment?
Courts decide whether conduct was within the scope of employment by asking whether it was typical of or broadly incidental to the employer’s business, or whether it was a foreseeable outgrowth of the employee’s job. The conduct does not have to be authorized, and it can even violate company rules, as long as it is connected to the work.
In Lisa M. v. Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital (1995) 12 Cal.4th 291, the California Supreme Court explained that the employee’s wrongful act must have a causal nexus to the employee’s duties, meaning the act was an outgrowth of the employment or a risk inherent in the enterprise. Courts look at factors such as:
- Whether the act occurred during working hours and at a work location
- Whether the employee was doing something to benefit the employer, even indirectly
- Whether the conduct arose from a work-related dispute or task
- Whether the type of harm was a foreseeable risk of the employer’s business
A delivery driver who causes a crash while making deliveries is within the scope of employment. An employee who commits an assault for purely personal reasons unrelated to the job usually is not.
Does Vicarious Liability Apply to Commuting and Personal Errands?
Generally, no. Under the going and coming rule, an employee is usually outside the scope of employment while commuting to and from work, so the employer is not vicariously liable for an accident during an ordinary commute. Courts recognize exceptions, such as when the employer requires the employee to use a personal vehicle for work, or when the employee is on a special errand for the employer.
Personal detours raise similar questions. A minor deviation, like stopping for coffee during a work trip, may still be within the scope of employment, while a substantial departure for personal reasons may not. Our detailed guide to the going and coming rule walks through how courts draw these lines.
Are Businesses Liable for Independent Contractors?
Usually not. A business that hires a true independent contractor is generally not vicariously liable for the contractor’s negligence, because it does not control how the work is done. The label in the contract is not decisive, however. Courts look at the actual relationship, including who controls the details of the work, who supplies tools, and whether the work is part of the hiring business’s regular operations.
There are important exceptions. A business may be liable for a contractor’s conduct when it owes a nondelegable duty, such as certain safety duties imposed by law, or when the work is inherently dangerous. A hiring party can also face direct liability for its own negligence in selecting or supervising the contractor. Under the doctrine from Privette v. Superior Court (1993) 5 Cal.4th 689, a hirer is generally not liable for injuries to the contractor’s own employees, subject to limited exceptions.
When Is a Vehicle Owner Liable for Someone Else’s Driving?
A vehicle owner in California can be liable for injuries caused by anyone who drives the vehicle with the owner’s permission, but that liability is capped by statute. Under Vehicle Code sections 17150 and 17151, the owner’s permissive-use liability is generally limited to $15,000 for injury or death to one person, $30,000 for all persons in one accident, and $5,000 for property damage.
These caps do not apply when the owner is also directly at fault, such as by negligently entrusting the car to a driver known to be unsafe, or when the driver was the owner’s employee acting within the scope of employment. In those situations, full respondeat superior or negligence liability may apply. Transportation businesses face an even higher standard of care, discussed in our article on common carrier negligence.
What Damages and Defenses Apply in Vicarious Liability Cases?
An employer held vicariously liable is responsible for the same compensatory damages as the employee, including medical expenses, lost earnings, property damage, and pain and suffering. Punitive damages are different. Under Civil Code section 3294(b), an employer is liable for punitive damages based on an employee’s conduct only if an officer, director, or managing agent had advance knowledge of the employee’s unfitness and acted with conscious disregard, authorized or ratified the conduct, or was personally guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice.
Common defenses include showing that the employee was acting outside the scope of employment, that the worker was a genuine independent contractor, that the going and coming rule applies, or that the injured party’s own comparative fault reduces damages. Employers who pay a judgment caused entirely by an employee’s fault may in some cases seek indemnity from that employee, though this is rarely practical.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an employer be liable for an employee’s intentional misconduct?
Yes, in some cases. If the intentional act grew out of the employee’s job, such as a dispute over work, or was a foreseeable risk of the business, the employer may be vicariously liable. If the act was motivated purely by personal reasons unrelated to the work, courts usually find it outside the scope of employment and the employer is not liable.
Is a parent vicariously liable for a child’s actions?
California imposes limited parental liability by statute. Civil Code section 1714.1 makes parents liable, up to a capped amount, for willful misconduct by a minor child that causes injury or property damage. Parents can also be directly liable for their own negligence, such as negligent supervision or allowing a child access to a dangerous item.
Can I sue both the employee and the employer?
Yes. An injured person can name both the employee who caused the harm and the employer that is vicariously liable. The employer is usually the more practical source of recovery because it typically carries liability insurance. Naming both also allows the court to resolve all liability questions, including scope of employment, in one case.
How Can Wade Litigation Help With a Vicarious Liability Claim?
Whether you were injured by someone acting for a business or you are an employer facing a claim based on an employee’s conduct, the scope of employment question often decides who pays. Wade Litigation, a California civil litigation firm with offices in Los Gatos and Redondo Beach, handles these disputes throughout California and can evaluate the relationships, evidence, and insurance involved. Contact Wade Litigation to discuss your situation.
Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Wade Litigation. For guidance on your situation, please speak with a licensed California attorney.
Clients Throughout California
Fields Marked With An โ*โ Are Required