phn icon

Call For A Consultation
408-214-5225

How California Courts Assess Fraudulent Joinder Claims

Federal courthouse with marble columns, the setting for removal and remand disputes

Last reviewed: November 15, 2026

Fraudulent joinder is a federal court doctrine that allows a defendant to remove a lawsuit from California state court to federal court by showing that a non-diverse defendant was named only to block removal and cannot possibly be liable. If the federal court agrees, it disregards that defendant and keeps the case. If not, the case is sent back to state court. This article explains how removal works, what fraudulent joinder means, the strict standard federal courts in California apply, and how remand disputes are resolved.

How Does Removal From State Court to Federal Court Work?

Removal is the process a defendant uses to transfer a case filed in state court to federal court. Under 28 U.S.C. section 1441, a defendant can remove a civil case if the federal court would have had original jurisdiction over it. For cases based on state law claims, that usually means diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. section 1332, which requires complete diversity of citizenship between all plaintiffs and all defendants and an amount in controversy over $75,000.

Defendants often prefer federal court because of its procedures, judges, and jury pools. Plaintiffs who file in a California superior court often want to stay there. Because a single California defendant can destroy complete diversity when the plaintiff is also a California citizen, the decision about whom to name as a defendant can determine which court hears the case. This choice matters in many types of civil litigation, including employment, insurance, and product cases.

What Is Fraudulent Joinder?

Fraudulent joinder, sometimes called improper joinder, describes a situation where a plaintiff names a non-diverse defendant who has no real chance of being held liable, apparently to prevent removal. Despite the name, it does not require proof of actual fraud or bad intent by the plaintiff. The question is whether the claim against the non-diverse defendant is legally viable.

In the Ninth Circuit, which covers federal courts in California, a defendant can establish fraudulent joinder in two ways: by showing actual fraud in the pleading of jurisdictional facts, or by showing that the plaintiff cannot establish a cause of action against the non-diverse defendant in state court. The Ninth Circuit described these two paths in Hunter v. Philip Morris USA (9th Cir. 2009) 582 F.3d 1039. In practice, almost all cases turn on the second path.

What Standard Do Federal Courts in California Apply?

Federal courts in California apply a demanding standard that strongly favors remand. Courts start with a strong presumption against removal, and the removing defendant bears the burden of proving that removal was proper.

In GranCare, LLC v. Thrower (9th Cir. 2018) 889 F.3d 543, the Ninth Circuit held that if there is any possibility that a state court would find the complaint states a cause of action against the non-diverse defendant, the federal court must find the joinder proper and remand the case. The court also explained that the fraudulent joinder inquiry is different from a motion to dismiss: a claim that is poorly pleaded may still be viable if the plaintiff could fix it by amending the complaint.

The Ninth Circuit has also described the defendant’s burden as heavy, requiring clear and convincing evidence in Hamilton Materials, Inc. v. Dow Chemical Corp. (9th Cir. 2007) 494 F.3d 1203. As a result, fraudulent joinder arguments succeed only when the claim against the in-state defendant is plainly barred, for example by a clear statutory immunity or a defense that applies as a matter of law.

Which Situations Commonly Raise Fraudulent Joinder Arguments?

Fraudulent joinder arguments arise most often when a plaintiff sues an out-of-state company along with an individual or local business located in California. Common examples include:

  • Employment cases naming a California supervisor or manager alongside an out-of-state employer
  • Product cases naming a local retailer or distributor along with an out-of-state manufacturer
  • Insurance cases naming a California-based claims adjuster or agent along with a non-California insurer
  • Real estate and lending cases naming a local trustee or servicer along with a national lender

In each situation, the defendant argues that California law gives the plaintiff no viable claim against the local party. For example, in product cases, the analysis depends on whether a retailer or distributor can be held strictly liable, an issue discussed in our guide to California product liability claims.

How Do Remand Disputes Get Resolved?

After removal, the plaintiff can file a motion to remand. Under 28 U.S.C. section 1447(c), a motion to remand based on a defect other than lack of subject matter jurisdiction must be filed within 30 days after the notice of removal. A lack of subject matter jurisdiction can be raised at any time before final judgment.

The court decides the motion by reviewing the complaint, and it may consider summary-judgment-type evidence, such as declarations about the non-diverse defendant’s role. Doubts are resolved in favor of remand. If the court finds the joinder was proper, it sends the case back to state court and may award the plaintiff the costs and attorney fees caused by removal when the defendant lacked an objectively reasonable basis for removing, as the U.S. Supreme Court explained in Martin v. Franklin Capital Corp. (2005) 546 U.S. 132.

An order remanding a case to state court based on lack of jurisdiction or a removal defect generally cannot be appealed, under 28 U.S.C. section 1447(d). That makes the remand decision effectively final for most cases, which can significantly affect the overall timeline of the lawsuit.

What Deadlines Apply to Removal?

A defendant generally must file a notice of removal within 30 days after being served with the complaint or receiving a document that first makes the case removable, under 28 U.S.C. section 1446(b). A case cannot be removed based on diversity more than one year after it was filed in state court, unless the court finds that the plaintiff acted in bad faith to prevent removal.

These deadlines create strategy on both sides. A defendant who believes a local defendant was improperly joined must act within the 30-day window. A plaintiff who later dismisses the local defendant may make the case removable, but only if the one-year limit has not passed or bad faith is shown.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does fraudulent joinder require proof that the plaintiff acted dishonestly?

No. Despite the name, fraudulent joinder usually has nothing to do with dishonesty. A defendant only needs to show that the plaintiff has no possible claim against the non-diverse defendant under state law. The plaintiff’s motive for naming that defendant is generally not the focus, although actual fraud in pleading jurisdictional facts is a separate ground.

Can a plaintiff amend the complaint to defeat a fraudulent joinder argument?

Federal courts consider whether the plaintiff could cure a deficient claim against the non-diverse defendant by amendment. If a viable claim could be stated, the joinder is generally proper. However, a plaintiff who seeks to add a new non-diverse defendant after removal faces a separate analysis under 28 U.S.C. section 1447(e), and the court has discretion to deny the amendment.

Is a remand order appealable?

Generally not. Under 28 U.S.C. section 1447(d), an order remanding a case to state court for lack of subject matter jurisdiction or a defect in removal is not reviewable on appeal, with limited statutory exceptions. Because of this, the parties usually get only one chance to argue the fraudulent joinder issue in the federal district court.

How Can Wade Litigation Help With Removal and Remand Disputes?

Choosing the right court can shape every part of a case, from discovery to trial. Wade Litigation, a California civil and business litigation firm with offices in Los Gatos and Redondo Beach, represents plaintiffs and defendants throughout California in removal, remand, and forum disputes, along with the underlying claims. Our business litigation practice regularly handles cases involving out-of-state companies. Contact Wade Litigation to discuss your case.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Wade Litigation. For guidance on your situation, please speak with a licensed California attorney.

Representing
Clients Throughout California

Fields Marked With An โ€*โ€ Are Required

Categories
Categories
Archives
Archives