phn icon

Call For A Consultation
408-214-5225

How California Courts Assess Litigation Privilege Defenses

Attorney standing beside a seated client in a law office with scales of justice

Last reviewed: November 15, 2026

California’s litigation privilege makes statements made in or closely connected to court proceedings absolutely immune from most civil lawsuits, including claims for defamation, fraud, and emotional distress. The privilege comes from Civil Code section 47(b) and is designed to let parties, attorneys, and witnesses speak freely in litigation without fear of being sued for what they say. This article explains what the privilege covers, the test courts apply, how it reaches pre-litigation communications, and the exceptions that limit it.

What Is California’s Litigation Privilege?

The litigation privilege is a rule in California Civil Code section 47(b) that makes a publication or broadcast made in a judicial proceeding, legislative proceeding, or other official proceeding authorized by law privileged. In practice, it bars tort claims based on communications made in connection with lawsuits, arbitrations, and many administrative proceedings.

The privilege is absolute. It applies even if the statement was false, made with malice, or intended to harm someone. Courts accept that result because the privilege serves important goals: giving people free access to the courts, encouraging open testimony, and ensuring that disputes are resolved in the original case rather than through a second round of lawsuits about what was said in the first one. For anyone sued over statements made in a court case, the privilege is often the first line of defense our lawsuit defense attorneys consider.

What Test Do Courts Use to Apply the Privilege?

Courts apply the four-part test from Silberg v. Anderson (1990) 50 Cal.3d 205. The privilege applies to any communication that is:

  1. Made in a judicial or quasi-judicial proceeding
  2. By litigants or other participants authorized by law
  3. To achieve the objects of the litigation
  4. Having some connection or logical relation to the action

Courts interpret these requirements broadly. Pleadings, briefs, declarations, testimony, discovery responses, settlement communications, demand letters, and statements to the court all usually qualify. The communication does not have to be relevant in a strict evidentiary sense; it only needs some logical connection to the case.

Who Is Protected by the Litigation Privilege?

The litigation privilege protects the parties to a case, their attorneys, witnesses, and other participants authorized by law, such as court-appointed evaluators, investigators, and mediators. It also protects people who are not formal parties but who participate in the proceeding in a recognized role.

In Rubin v. Green (1993) 4 Cal.4th 1187, the California Supreme Court applied the privilege to an attorney’s communications with prospective clients about filing a lawsuit, holding that claims based on those communications were barred. The decision shows how far the privilege extends to the preparation and pursuit of litigation, not just to what is said inside a courtroom.

The privilege covers communications in arbitrations and many administrative hearings as well, because those are official proceedings authorized by law. Statements made in internal company investigations or private disputes that never involve any official proceeding usually fall outside it, although other privileges may apply.

Does the Privilege Apply Before a Lawsuit Is Filed?

Yes, in many cases. The litigation privilege protects pre-litigation communications when litigation is contemplated in good faith and under serious consideration. The California Supreme Court adopted that standard in Action Apartment Association, Inc. v. City of Santa Monica (2007) 41 Cal.4th 1232.

A demand letter sent while a party is seriously considering a lawsuit is usually privileged. A threat of litigation made only as a bargaining tactic, with no real intent to sue, may not be. Courts look at the timing, the content of the communication, and whether the litigation was actually pursued or seriously evaluated. Investigative interviews, witness outreach, and reports to police or regulators can also be protected, although some reports to law enforcement are governed by other subdivisions of section 47.

Does the Privilege Protect Conduct as Well as Statements?

The privilege protects communications and communicative acts, not independent non-communicative conduct. In Kimmel v. Goland (1990) 51 Cal.3d 202, the California Supreme Court held that the privilege did not protect the illegal recording of telephone calls, even though the recordings were made to gather evidence for litigation, because the recording itself was conduct rather than a communication.

Courts draw the line by asking whether the gravamen of the claim is a communication or an act. Filing a lawsuit, serving a subpoena, or sending a demand letter is communicative. Physically seizing property, destroying evidence, or trespassing to obtain documents is conduct and usually falls outside the privilege.

What Are the Exceptions to the Litigation Privilege?

The most important exception is malicious prosecution. A person who was the target of a baseless lawsuit can sue for malicious prosecution if the case ended in their favor, was brought without probable cause, and was initiated with malice. The privilege does not bar that claim.

Section 47(b) also contains statutory exceptions, including:

  • Certain allegations in marital dissolution or legal separation pleadings made about a person against whom no relief is sought, unless specific requirements are met
  • Communications made in furtherance of the intentional destruction or alteration of physical evidence to deprive a party of its use
  • A recorded notice of pending action, often called a lis pendens, which is privileged only if it identifies an action that affects title to or possession of real property

The lis pendens rule matters in property disputes, where a recorded notice can cloud title and stall a sale. Breach of contract claims can also survive in some cases, such as when a party agreed not to make certain statements and then made them in litigation, depending on whether applying the privilege would further its purposes.

How Does the Litigation Privilege Relate to Anti-SLAPP Motions?

The litigation privilege and the anti-SLAPP statute often work together. Statements made in court proceedings are protected activity under Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16, so a defendant sued over litigation communications can usually bring an anti-SLAPP motion. At the second step, the plaintiff must show the claim has minimal merit, and the litigation privilege frequently defeats that showing.

When both doctrines apply, the defendant can often end the case early and recover attorney fees. Our guide to the anti-SLAPP commercial speech exception explains one situation where the anti-SLAPP statute does not apply, even though the litigation privilege still might. These issues come up often in civil litigation involving former business partners, family members, and neighbors.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue someone for lying about me in court documents?

Usually not. Statements in pleadings, declarations, and testimony are protected by the litigation privilege, even if false or malicious. The remedy is generally within the original case, through evidence, cross-examination, sanctions, or a perjury referral. If the entire lawsuit was baseless and ended in your favor, a malicious prosecution claim may be available.

Are statements made at a deposition privileged?

Yes. Deposition testimony and statements made by attorneys during a deposition are made in a judicial proceeding by participants authorized by law and are connected to the case. They are covered by the litigation privilege and generally cannot form the basis of a defamation or similar tort claim.

Does the privilege protect statements to the media about a lawsuit?

Usually not. Statements made to the press or on social media are generally not made to achieve the objects of the litigation, so they fall outside section 47(b). A party who repeats allegations publicly may face a defamation claim, although other defenses, such as the fair report privilege for accurate reports of court proceedings, may apply.

How Can Wade Litigation Help With a Litigation Privilege Issue?

If you have been sued over something said in a lawsuit, or you believe someone misused the courts against you, the litigation privilege and its exceptions will shape your options. Wade Litigation, a California civil litigation firm with offices in Los Gatos and Redondo Beach, represents clients throughout California in privilege, anti-SLAPP, and malicious prosecution disputes. Contact Wade Litigation to discuss your case.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Wade Litigation. For guidance on your situation, please speak with a licensed California attorney.

Representing
Clients Throughout California

Fields Marked With An โ€*โ€ Are Required

Categories
Categories
Archives
Archives