The burden of proof determines who must prove their claims in a lawsuit and to what degree. Unlike criminal cases, where the standard is “beyond a reasonable doubt,” civil cases have different proof requirements that can make or break your case.
At Wade Litigation, we help clients navigate civil litigation by ensuring they meet the necessary burden of proof to win their cases.
Contents
Who Bears the Burden of Proof in a Civil Case?
In most civil lawsuits, the plaintiff (the party bringing the lawsuit) carries the burden of proof. This means they must provide enough evidence to convince the court that their claim is valid. However, defendants may also bear a burden of proof when asserting counterclaims or affirmative defenses.
Levels of Proof in Civil Cases
The burden of proof in a civil case varies depending on the type of lawsuit. Here are the key legal standards:
1. Preponderance of the Evidence (Most Common Standard)
- Used in contract disputes, personal injury cases, and general civil lawsuits.
- The plaintiff must prove that their claims are more likely true than not (51% probability).
- Example: If a business owner sues for breach of contract, they must show it is more likely than not that the other party failed to meet their contractual obligations.
2. Clear and Convincing Evidence (Higher Standard)
- Used in cases involving fraud, wills & trusts disputes, and punitive damages claims.
- The plaintiff must present evidence that is highly probable or reasonably certain.
- Example: If you claim that a will was forged due to undue influence, you must provide substantial evidence to prove your case.
3. Beyond a Reasonable Doubt (Rare in Civil Cases)
- This is the highest standard, used mainly in criminal cases.
- However, some civil cases involving fraud or penalties may require a near-criminal standard of proof.
How Defendants Can Shift the Burden of Proof
Although the burden of proof starts with the plaintiff, a defendant can shift the burden by introducing affirmative defenses such as:
- Self-defense (in cases of civil assault claims).
- Comparative negligence (in personal injury lawsuits).
- Statute of limitations (if the plaintiff’s lawsuit was filed too late).
If the defendant successfully proves an affirmative defense, the burden shifts back to the plaintiff to disprove it.
Types of Evidence That Can Strengthen Your Case
Meeting the burden of proof requires strong evidence, which can include:
- Documentary evidence – Contracts, receipts, medical records, and emails.
- Witness testimony – Statements from people with direct knowledge of the case.
- Expert opinions – Testimony from professionals (e.g., doctors, forensic accountants, or engineers).
- Physical evidence – Photos, videos, and other tangible proof.
Challenges in Meeting the Burden of Proof
Even with strong evidence, plaintiffs face challenges such as:
- Lack of sufficient documentation.
- Defendants presenting counterarguments or contradictory evidence.
- Judicial bias or misinterpretation of legal standards.
Working with an experienced civil litigation attorney is crucial to ensuring that your case meets the necessary proof standards.
How Wade Litigation Can Help
At Wade Litigation, we specialize in civil litigation strategies that help plaintiffs and defendants navigate the complexities of the burden of proof. Our services include:
- Assessing your case’s strength based on evidence.
- Building compelling arguments that meet the legal standard.
- Challenging the opposition’s claims and shifting the burden when necessary.
Secure Your Legal Victory Today
The burden of proof can determine the outcome of your civil case. Don’t take chances—contact Wade Litigation today for expert legal guidance and ensure your case is built on solid legal ground.