Differences Between State and Federal Civil Litigation Cases

Civil litigation in the United States operates under two distinct court systems—state and federal. Each system has its own set of rules, procedures, and jurisdictions, which can significantly impact the strategy of a legal case. Understanding the main differences between these systems and the process of escalating a state civil litigation case to a federal court can be useful for litigants.

Grounds for Jurisdiction

  • State Courts: Typically handle cases that involve state law issues, contracts, and family law disputes that occur within their borders.
  • Federal Courts: Reserved for cases involving federal laws, disputes between states, and cases where the parties are from different states but the dispute involves amounts exceeding $75,000.

Procedural Differences

  • Process and Pacing: Federal courts are generally stricter with procedural rules and have more streamlined processes, which can lead to quicker civil litigation case resolutions.
  • Discovery Laws: Federal discovery rules are often more expansive, allowing broader evidence gathering than many state courts.

Escalating to Federal Court

The process of moving a case from state to federal court is known as “removal.” It is typically sought by defendants who believe that a federal court may provide a more favorable setting due to its broader jurisdiction or perceived neutrality. For removal to be successful, the case must involve a federal question or meet the criteria for diversity jurisdiction. Here’s how it unfolds:

  • Filing a Notice of Removal: The defendant must file this notice in both the state court where the case was originally filed and the court they wish to transfer to.
  • Timing: This must be done within 30 days of receiving the initial complaint.
  • Approval: The federal court will then decide whether the case meets the federal criteria for jurisdiction and either accept or remand the civil litigation case back to the state court.

For individuals and businesses navigating through these complexities, we offer expert guidance to determine the most strategic court system for their civil litigation needs. Understanding these differences and the removal process is useful for leveraging the appropriate jurisdiction in civil cases, ensuring litigants make informed decisions about their legal strategies.

Checkout our 144 reviews